Lennart Nilsson Photography Home Page
Skip Navigation Links
Abortion ImagesExpand Abortion Images
Skip Navigation Links
Contact UsExpand Contact Us
Skip Navigation Links
About UsExpand About Us
Skip Navigation Links
Articles/PublicationsExpand Articles/Publications

Dinesh D’Souza calls AbandonedTHE BEST BOOK ever written on abortion!” D’Souza is a New York Times best-selling author of multiple volumes and is the director of 2016: Obama's America, the "No. 1, largest-grossing conservative documentary ever....." --- quote is from the Washington Times

Abandoned called “…the Uncle Tom’s Cabin of the abortion issue.” --- Jack Ames

Click on the image of the book cover on the left to order the book or call 1-800-437-5876.
Skip Navigation Links
RedRoseRescueArchiveExpand RedRoseRescueArchive
See our new website that features
Images of Abortion.
These are unborn babies
Retrieved from
Womans Choice dumpster,
Lansing, MI
by Chris Veneklase,
Feb. 26, 2010.
All photos taken by CPLS.
New Study Shows Abortion
Victim Photos Are Effective
CPLS Director Explains Importance
of Use of Abortion Victim Photos
LifeSite News Interview
Click image for Story and Interview
Comments on the Gosnell Trial
Click here for "Seven Reasons
Why Abortion is the Preeminent
Social/Political Issue"
(printable .pdf)
Here is what can be found
in the Archives:
Now That Trump Has Won
Womans Choice Clinic
Dumpster Scandal (2010)
Skip Navigation Links
Womans Choice ScandalExpand Womans Choice Scandal
Womens Advisory Center Dumpster Scandal Abortionist Sharpe (2008)
Skip Navigation Links
Sharpe Dumpster ScandalExpand Sharpe Dumpster Scandal
Woman Care Clinic
Dumpster Scandal
Abortionist Hodari (2008)
Skip Navigation Links
The Hodari Dumpster ScandalExpand The Hodari Dumpster Scandal
Notre Dame Protest  Arrests and Litigation Updates (2009-ongoing)
Skip Navigation Links
Notre Dame ControversyExpand Notre Dame Controversy
The Owosso Incident and the New York Times Coup
Skip Navigation Links
The Owosso IncidentExpand The Owosso Incident
The Dingell Town Hall and HealthCare Reform Deception
Skip Navigation Links
The HealthCare Reform ScamExpand The HealthCare Reform Scam
The Tiller Killing
Skip Navigation Links
The Tiller KillingExpand The Tiller Killing
Demonstrations, Activism and Other Information
Skip Navigation Links
ActivismExpand Activism
Skip Navigation Links
SummariesExpand Summaries

Over 160 Services to Choose From!
Memorial Services to Be Conducted at the Actual Graves of Aborted Babies
Or at the Hundreds of Memorial Markers for Aborted Babies
All Locations for Babies’ Graves and Markers Can be Found at:
Hand of Michael Gabrielle, aborted by Michael Roth, Michigan abortionist and found in the trunk of his car Sept. 2015 with 14 others. Baby named by pro-lifers and buried Nov. 24th, 2018 at Holy Spirit Parish Cemetery, Brighton, MI. This burial is the very latest burial of a victim of abortion.
Archbishop Allen Vigneron to Officiate at Memorial Service at Holy Sepulchre Cemetery, Southfield, MI.

Two Priests Among Those Arrested in Red Rose Rescue, July 13, 2019

And Two Women Turned Away During the Rescue at New Jersey Abortion Facility

Charged With Trespassing, All Four Rescuers Were Released On Their Own Recognizance

See Below LifeSite News Article with Many Photos!
See Below News Articles with Many Photos!
During the Rescue one woman who began to weep left the abortion facility. Another woman, about 18 years old, whose mother was pressuring her to abort her baby, also left with her mother after sidewalk counselors talked to her. These are "turn-aways" from abortion and we can only PRAY that their babies will be saved. Thanks to the Red Rose Rescue, the babies are alive as of July 13th.

Friday, June 7th Pro-Lifers Conduct
Red Rose Rescue at Women's Center
Abortion Clinic in Flint, MI.
Four of the Rescuers Arrested When They Opted to Stay in the Abortion Center
in Solidarity with the Unborn
About to Be Executed
See Links to News Stories Below Secular Press Was Very Fair!!
25 year-old Lauren Handy arrested for protecting the unborn
at Flint, MI abortion clinic, June 7, 2019

On Friday, June 7th, at approximately 8:30am 7 pro-lifers entered the abortion facility of the Women’s Center of Flint, MI, 3422 Flushing Rd. including your Citizens for a Pro-Life Society director. We sat down next to women seated in the waiting room and offered them material help and words of encouragement to leave the clinic and choose life for their babies. We had about 10 minutes to counsel the women before clinic staff rounded them up and ushered them into a hallway off of the waiting room.

At this point the rescuers sang hymns, prayed and tried to communicate with the women who were just in the next hallway. Your CPLS director left the clinic when one of the women came out of the back hallway and exited the facility. I hoped to talk to her in the parking lot and tried to persuade her to give life to her baby. Sadly however, she went back into the abortion clinic. While the rescue continued I stayed in the parking lot and continued to counsel other women who were arriving for their abortions.

In the meantime one of the rescuers, Rhonda, was actually able to gain access to the back hallway as the clinic staff believed she was one of their customers. She attempted to talk to the moms and offer them literature. When one of the women said: "Why are you back here with us?" Rhonda cleverly replied: "I'm back here with you because like your mother, my mother gave me life!"

A few of the women in the waiting room did take red roses offered to them and pro-life pamphlets as well. I was able to leave pro-life literature on a shelf near chairs in the waiting room before I left the clinic.

Police place Matthew Connolly and Patrice Woodworth under arrest
during June 7, 2019 at Women's Center of Flint, MI
abortion clinic in Red Rose Rescue.

Four of the rescuers stayed in the clinic refusing to leave when told to do so by law enforcement when a contingent of ten Flint Township offers arrived! The four rescuers intended to offer an act of non-violent defense of unborn children about to be aborted. The philosophy of the Red Rose Rescue is that the unborn scheduled for abortion are the true outcasts of society--they are the abandoned and the unwanted--and they deserve to have someone BE WITH THEM as they are about to go off to their execution. Moreover, we know, after this, the 14th Red Rose Rescue, that as long as there is a pro-life presence inside the abortion center--the killing is stopped!

The June 7th Red Rose Rescue is the 3rd such Rescue to take place in Michigan since the first took place Sept. 15, 2017 at the Northland Family Planning Clinic in Sterling Hts. Attached to each rose offered to the women is a card that states on one side “You were made to love and to be loved... your goodness is greater than the difficulties of your situation. Circumstances in life change. A new life, however tiny, brings the promise of unrepeatable joy.” Phone numbers of local pregnancy help centers are listed on the reverse side of the card.

Abortion clinic manager Peggy Thon films arrest of pro-life rescuer Patrice Woodworth.

The Flint abortion center is owned and operated by Michigan resident Victoria Moore who also owns an abortion center in Saginaw. Theodore Roumell first performs abortions at the Saginaw facility while women, told to arrive at 8:30 at the Flint clinic, wait literally for hours for the abortionist to arrive. Second trimester abortions are conducted Mondays and are performed by abortionist Reginald Sharpe.

Monica Migliorino Miller, director of Citizens for a Pro-Life Society organizer of the Red Rose Rescue explains: “The Red Rose Rescue is an act of charity for women who feel for whatever reason they must have their innocent unborn children killed. Those who take part are willing to embrace risks for these women and their babies. We will go into the very places where the unborn are put to death and extend help to the moms. Should this help be refused—we will not leave the abortion centers but remain in solidarity with the helpless victims oppressed by the injustice of abortion. Saint Mother Teresa of Calcutta said that her work was ‘to go into the dark holes of the poor.’ The Red Rose Rescue is an action of going into the dark holes of the poor where the innocent are rejected—and in these dark holes we seek to bring love, hope, and true peace to the women scheduled for abortions, encouraging them to choose life.” (Photo above: Will Goodman under arrest)

Those arrested at the clinic June 7th are William Goodman, Lauren Handy, Patrice Woodworth and Matthew Connolly, ranging in age from 50 to 25 years of age. They expect to be arraigned before a judge on Monday, June 10th. PLEASE PLEASE PRAY FOR THEM-- AND PRAY FOR A WOMAN NAMED TAYLA-- A WOMAN I COUNSELED FOR OVER 20 MINUTES WHO MAY COME BACK TO THE CLINIC FOR 2nd Trimester ABORTION!
Here are news stories on the Rescue--
Indeed Lots of secular media covered it !!

Picture of aborted baby leaves pro-abortion lawmakers speechless
click on the image below to go to LifeSite News to read the article and to view the video of of Dr. Miller's presentation
click on the link below to go to YouTube to hear Dr. Miller's presentation

2018 Ends With Two Red Rose Rescues
A Couple Left the Planned Parenthood Abortion Center in New Jersey!
Pray for Them!
See News Stories Below— Including Secular Press,
The Trentonian
Fr. Stehpen Imbarrato talks to police officers outside the door of the Washington, DC
Surgi-Center during the Dec. 20th Red Rose Rescue.

Two Red Rose Rescues took place just before Christmas—the first December 20th at the Washington Surgi-Center, in which the abortion center was essentially shut down for over 3 hours due to the presence of the rescuers—namely Fr. Stephen Imbarrato, Linda Mueller and Laura Gies.

The second RRR occurred at the Planned Parenthood abortion center in Trenton, New Jersey on December 22. This is the first time that an RRR occurred at a Planned Parenthood abortion center. At about 9am four Red Rose Rescuers entered the abortion center at 437 State Street in Trenton—Fr. Fidelis Moscinski of the Franciscan Friars of the Renewal, William Goodman, Patrice Woodward and Matthew Connolly. Six women were already seated in the waiting room, two of them Hispanic couples accompanied by their boyfriends. Will Goodman spoke to one of the Hispanic couples. He gave them literature, talked to them about the humanity of their unborn child and gave them a red rose which they accepted. During the course of the rescue the couple, who definitely were there for an abortion, got up and left the PP abortion facility.

All of the women in the PP clinic were counseled by the Red Rose Rescuers and were given roses before the Planned Parenthood staff moved the women to another part of the abortion facility. At that point the rescuers stayed in the waiting room praying and singing hymns until the police arrived. The officers warned the rescuers that they were trespassing. But Fr. Fidelis and Will Goodman explained that their presence was needed to defend the unborn scheduled for execution stating: “We cannot leave. Innocent unborn children are about to be put to death and we have opted to stay with them.”


The goals of a Red Rose Rescue are two-fold:

a) to offer help and words of encouragement to the mothers, to persuade them to turn away from their abortion decision and

b) to offer a loving act of defense on behalf of the unborn about to be aborted—to abide with them in the moment of their abandonment.

(Photo at left: Fr. Fidelis Moscinski placed under arrest at Planned Parenthood in Trenton New Jersey. Photo by Fr. William Kuchzinski)

This is why Red Rose Rescuers do not leave the abortion centers—they do not leave—they must be removed.

At the RRR in D.C. the three rescuers entered the abortion facility a little after 9am. They made an effort to talk to the mothers. After several minutes however the women were told to move to a “back room” away from the rescuers. Since the clinic is located in a high-rise building the rescuers made a clever decision to exit the waiting room and stay in the hallway near the door of the facility. Now they had access to all of the other women coming for their abortions! Clinic staff having no authority to remove the rescuers from the building hallway, Fr. Stephen, Linda and Laura remained there for nearly three hours until the building manager could be located. The police who had arrived in the meantime had no authority to remove the rescuers until the manager indicated that he did not want the rescuers inside his building. Only then were Fr. Stephen, Linda and Laura placed under arrest.

Upon their release from jail, rescuers returned to the Planned Parenthood in Trenton, N.J. to pray for the mothers and the staff, and for an end to abortion. Pro-life rescue heroine Joan Andrews Bell (in yellow hat) knelling in prayer. Fr. Fidelis is to her right. Patrice Woodworth is at extreme right. Matthew Connolly is knelling 2nd from left.
Photo by Monica Miller—CPLS Director

While they were in the hallway abortionist Cesare F. Santangelo never arrived. The Washington Surgi-enter was thus shut down for over three hours. This abortion center has seen its share of scandal and controversy.

Lifesite News reports:

Washington Surgi-Clinic is one of the 19 abortion facilities in the DC metropolitan area. Known for providing late-term abortions, Cesare F. Santangelo has a history of medical malpractice. Court documents obtained by Operation Rescue showed a 2011 medical malpractice/wrongful death lawsuit filed by the family of a women who died during an abortion.

A 2013 undercover video from Live Action showed that Santangelo [was willing to leave] a baby struggling for life to die after a failed abortion. “Hopefully we’ll get this pregnancy out intact, but it doesn’t always happen that way,” Santangelo [told] an undercover Live Action investigator who [was] 24 weeks pregnant. “I try and sever the umbilical cord first, and we wait for that to stop pulsing, and this way the fetus is expired first.”


We Had An Incredible Year Defending the Unborn and Working for a Culture of Life
Below is just a sample of our 2018 activities—
Not the Least of Which Was Defending the Unborn and Reaching Out to Their Mothers in the Red Rose Rescues
Young protestor makes her statement during a CPLS 2018 picket of Planned Parenthood
This Christmas Season Will You Please Consider a Tax-Deductible Donation to CPLS? We are very much in need of your support!
Help CPLS Continue Our Life-Saving Work.
For a donation of $45.00 or more – you will be sent a signed copy of my book: Abandoned—the Untold Story of the Abortion Wars.
Donate by sending check to:
Citizens for a Pro-Life Society
67919 Eight Mile Rd.
South Lyon, MI 48178
Or Click on this PayPal "Donate"  button
CPLS is on the Front Lines—Witnessing to the Sanctity of Life in the Public Square, CPLS is one of the National Organizers of the Protest PP Events. This Year the Protest PP was April 23—with 80 Protests all over the United States
Members of CPLS gather outside of Planned Parenthood in Ferndale, MI.

CPLS Continues to Help Women in Difficult Pregnancies. Here is Jennifer’s Baby Saved From a 2nd Trimester Abortion!
CPLS Organized and Participated in the Red Rose Rescues
Matthew Connelly arrested defending the unborn at the
Women’s Center abortion clinic in West Bloomfield, MI
—for which he served a 32 day jail term in June-July 2018.

Red Rose Rescuers, including your CPLS director, stood trial twice in 2018, before judges and jurors we proclaimed, contrary to the way of the world, that the unborn are human beings with a God-given Right to Life, deserving a defense such as we offered to them in Red Rose Rescues. Your CPLS director, Patrice Woodworth, Matthew Connolly and Will Goodman endured the most outrageous probation restrictions, one of which was to remain 500 feet from every abortion center in the United States. In conscience we could not comply with these unjust restrictions. We broke the probation. Will and I for instance, on June 1st, went back to the Women’s Center abortion “clinic” in West Bloomfield, MI. where we conducted the RRR for which we were arrested and stood trial—and even when I was forbidden to be there, I talked a woman out of an abortion! Judge Marc Barron found us “guilty” of violating the probation and we served 34-day jail terms courtesy of Oakland County Jail. Matthew too was later found guilty of the same “offense” and also served a similar sentence!

In a June 29th hearing before Judge Barron the abortion center manager, Pam DiMaggio testified that our Red Rose Rescue stopped no less than 12 women from going through with their abortions! It was an INCREDIBLE victory!! The clinic wanted us to pay restitution for lost revenue—and thankfully Judge Barron ruled against the clinic’s demand. Not that we would ever have paid a single cent!

Red Rose Rescues also took place in 2018 in Washington DC and Montclair, New Jersey. Three priests have been arrested defending the unborn: Fr. Stephen Imbarrato, Fr. David Nix and Fr. Fidelis Moscinski.

And two more Red Rose rescues took place to close out the year! One in Washington DC—the other in New Jersey—

Sept. 29—Red Rose Rescuers with your CPLS director (dark blue blazer) upon theirrel ease from the Montclair, NJ police lock-up. Will Goodman, Fr. Fidelis Moscinski, Patrice Woodworth and Matthew Connolly. Their trial is still pending. See Story at Top of the Home Page for Details.
CPLS is one of the Organizers for the
National Day of Remembrance for Aborted Babies
This year the solemn event took place September 8th
all over the United States.

A little girl places flowers on the grave of the “Hodari Babies” at the 2018 National Day of Remembrance—23 unborn babies killed by Alberto Hodari at his Lathrup Village, MI. abortion center. Found in 2008 by CPLS members in the dumpster behind the “clinic”. Photo: Richard Mucha.
And Then CPLS Buried the “Trunk Abortionist Babies.”

These are 15 unborn babies killed by Michigan abortionist Michael Roth (possibly doing abortions in hotel rooms) and found in the trunk of his car by West Bloomfield, MI. police officers. CPLS spent 2 years requesting the Oakland County Medical Examiner to give us the remains of these murder victims. Finally they were entrusted to us in August and CPLS planned two burial ceremonies Nov. 3rd and Nov. 24th. The Last Work of Mercy—to Bury the Dead was the First Work of Mercy these Babies Ever Knew in This World.

Coffin carrying the remains of Michael-Gabrielle, killed by abortionist Michael Roth and laid to rest in funeral planned by CPLS Nov. 24, 2018—buried at Holy Spirit Parish Cemetery, Brighton, MI. Photo: Emily Lizzio.
CPLS is helping Lynn Mills of Pro-life Michigan leading a dedicated battle to stop Planned Parenthood in Livonia, MI.

We recently picketed Phoenix Contractors, the company renovating the building purchase by PP after our many attempts to persuade the owner to pull out of the job! See here your CPLS director’s Guest Column that ran in the online and Sunday, Dec. 9, print edition of the Livonia Observer newspaper.

We assembled Nov. 28th outside of the Phoenix Contractor Company sending our message: Stop Building the PP Clinic in Livonia!—Photo: Lynn Mills

We Buried the Last of the “Trunk Abortionist” Babies on Saturday, Nov. 24th
See below a decent main stream media article! With very poignant photos!
Hand of Michael-Gabrielle, named by pro-lifers—aborted baby killed by Michigan abortionist Michael Roth and found in the trunk of his car with 14 others in September 2015
And PLEASE take the opportunity to respond on the newspaper's Facebook page here:
Also see the links at end of this memo to two great articles!! with Great Photos!
3 years after aborted fetus found
in trunk, remains buried in
Green Oak Township
Susan Bromley, Livingston Daily Published 1:44 p.m. ET Nov. 28, 2018
(Photo: Courtesy of Emily Lizzio)

A funeral for what pro-life activists say was a seven-week-old aborted baby they named Michael-Gabrielle was held on Saturday in Green Oak Township.

Monica Miller, director of Citizens for a Pro-Life Society, a national anti-abortion organization locally based in South Lyon, estimated that about 150 people attended the mass celebrated by Fr. John Rocus at the Holy Spirit Catholic Church and followed by a burial. Miller said the burial was the first in Livingston County for an aborted fetus.

"When we placed his or her body in the earth it was the only work of mercy this aborted human will ever know," Miller said. "And when we stand at the grave we commit ourselves to fight for a culture of life and an end to abortion.”

The aborted fetus was one of 15 in jars found by police in the trunk of Michael Roth's impounded car after he struck a pedestrian in September of 2015 in West Bloomfield Township. Police also found medications in the vehicle that were stolen from an Eastpointe abortion clinic where Roth had worked on occasion.

Casimir Miarka, administrator for the Oakland County Medical Examiner's office, said law enforcement brought the jars found in Roth's vehicle to her office on Oct. 8, 2015 for identification of the contents. He said the case did not fall under the jurisdiction of the medical examiner's office, which investigates and determines cause and manner of death in any violent, sudden, unexpected, suspicious or otherwise unexplained death.

"We deal with someone who has taken a breath and then passes," Miarka said. "Law enforcement brought it here so we could see what they were."

According to the medical examiner's report, Dr. Ljubisa Dragovic examined the tissue specimens and determined them to be products of conception.

Roth was originally charged with possession with intent to deliver schedule 2 narcotic Fentanyl, six counts of identity theft and three counts of larceny in a building. He was also charged with violating Michigan's public health code.


Roth pleaded no contest in October 2017 to three counts of larceny from a building and was sentenced to 18 months probation. Additionally, in a consent agreement with the state Board of Medicine, his license to practice medicine was suspended for one year and he was ordered to pay a $25,000 fine.

The jars and their contents were held by the medical examiner's office until the Michian Attorney General's office instructed them to be released to the Borek-Jennings Funeral Home in the Village of Hamburg in August.

A man places into the ground a coffin containing what pro-life activists say is a 7-week-old aborted fetus as mourners watch at the Holy Spirit Roman Catholic Cemetery in Brighton on Nov. 24, 2018. (Photo: Emily Lizzio)

Todd Borek, funeral home director, said he took the aborted babies into his care in August and kept them until he was able to facilitate their burials on behalf of Citizens for a Pro-Life Society, which had negotiated the release with the attorney general's office.

Earlier this month, Borek was present as 14 of the aborted babies were buried at Holy Sepulchre Cemetery in Southfield, and he also attended the burial of the 15th in Green Oak Township on Saturday.

"I am very pro-life and want to give a dignified burial, even if there is no next of kin," Borek said. "It's a privilege to help in any way."

A granite marker will be installed at the Holy Spirit Cemetery, engraved with the name Michael-Gabrielle, a designation as a victim of abortion and a verse from the book of Revelation, "He will wipe every tear from their eyes."

Miller said the burial symbolizes justice and shows the world human life is sacred.

"That grave is an indictment of our country that allows these innocent completely helpless human beings to be killed with sanction of law," Miller said. "I want to see Roe versus Wade reversed and laws put in place that recognize the value of every human being from the moment of conception."

A little more than 638,000 abortions were performed in the U.S. in 2015, the latest year for which data is available, according to a November report from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

That number is the lowest since abortion was legalized in 1973 through the landmark Roe v. Wade decision. The CDC's report also shows that the total number of abortions decreased by 24% from 2006-2015.

Ruth Lednicer, director of communications for Planned Parenthood of Michigan, believes the reason for the decrease in abortions is due to increased access to birth control and better sex education. She also believes that a mandate in the Affordable Care Act requiring insurance companies to include coverage for birth control with no co-pay had a positive effect.

"The abortion rate overall is falling, but it's still a legal, constitutionally protected right," Lednicer said.

"I would encourage people devoting their efforts to attending this burial to devote that same energy to preventing unintended pregnancies – through offering people access to fully comprehensive sex education and access to birth control."

Contact Livingston Daily reporter Susan Bromley at 517-552-2854 or sbromley@livingstondaily.com. Follow her on Twitter @SusanBromley10.

SEE Here LifeNews and LifeSite News Articles: Really Good!
Photos of the burial of the other 14 unborn babies killed by abortionist Michael Roth

Laid to rest Nov. 3, 2018 at
Holy Sepulchre Cemetery, Southfield, MI
Coffin of 14 “Trunk Abortionist” babies lowered into their grave, Nov. 3, 2018, Holy Sepulchre Cemetery, Southfield, MI. clockwise: Emmanuel Lughermo, Lynn Mills, Angelica Abbott and Connor Adams (from Protect Life Michigan) and your CPLS director in white jacket. Photo: Fr. William Kuszinsky
Students from Fr. Gabriel Richard High School in Ann Arbor, Michigan serve as pall bearers during funeral Mass at Transfiguration Parish, Southfield, MI Photo: Richard Mucha
Bishop Robert Fisher, auxiliary bishop of the Archdiocese of Detroit incenses the coffin containing the remains of 14 of the “Trunk Abortionist” babies during funeral Mass at Transfiguration Parish, Southfield, MI, Nov. 3, 2018 Photo: Richard Mucha

Responses to the Sidewalk Advocates for Life Video that Criticized the Red Rose Rescues
In late February 2018 Sidewalk Advocates for Life posted a video on You Tube entitled: “Desperate Measures.” It was a 23 minute-long criticism of Red Rose Rescues.
Citizens for a Pro-life Society has much respect for the work of SAFL and your CPLS director has spent literally decades outside of abortion centers sidewalk counseling women to not abort their babies since 1978. We feel that CPLS cannot simply stand by and not offer a response to the video.
We feature here the elegant rebuttal composed by veteran pro-lifer Richard Cowden Guido. I hope that you will read it!
Richard Cowden Guido
Also, at the end of this memo is the response of Abby McIntyre, the 21 year-old Indiana State college student who was arrested in the first RRR at the Northland Family Planning abortion center, Sept. 15, 2017 in Sterling Hts. MI.
Also—PLEASE see this excellent response that was issued by Operation Rescue.
Operation Rescue
Please pray for me—and my fellow Red Rose Rescuers Matthew Connolly, Will Goodman, Patrice Woodward and Robert Kolavy as we face sentencing March 14th for the Dec. 2, 2017 RRR we did at the Women’s Center abortion center in West Bloomfield, MI.
See below the Janet E. Smith and below the Abby McIntyre response details about that Red Rose Rescue and our court experience.

A Response to the Sidewalk Advocates for Life anti Red Rose Rescue Video Offered by Professor Janet E. Smith

Janet E. Smith

Fr. Michael J. McGivney
Chair of Life Ethics
Sacred Heart Major Seminary, Detroit, MI

(The views expressed here are entirely my own and not of the institution.)
Sidewalk Advocates for Life have put out a video arguing that the work of “rescuing groups” such as Red Rose Rescue is damaging to the pro-life movement. Of course they are to be commended for their dedication to saving the lives of the unborn and ministering to the women who seek abortion and those accompanying them. Their desire to protect the work they do is laudable.
They have, it seems, three major concerns:

1) that should rescuing groups continue their work, legal systems will push and push successfully to have buffer zones put in place around abortion mills not only for the abortion mills occupied by rescuers but mills in the near-by area and beyond. This would make it nearly impossible for side-walk counselors to have access to those entering abortion mills and thus many fewer lives would be saved.

2) They argue that such rescues are ineffective for saving lives; that the abortion mills quickly move the women into protected areas and abortions proceed apace.

3) They find the arrival of the police to be terribly upsetting to the women and the staff, who then view the rescuers as fanatical law-breakers, whereas those who come day in and day out in all kinds of weather to sidewalk counsel make a powerful impression because of their perseverance.
These are not baseless concerns. Their concerns deserve a response.
Prof. Monica Migliorino Miller who has served the prolife movement in nearly every possible capacity, filmed a brief justification for the action of Red Rose Rescue six months before the Sidewalk Advocacy Group produced its video. It is hard to imagine a more dedicated pro-lifer than Prof Miller. She has spent months in jail for her attempts to rescue the unborn, once as the mother of a newborn. She regularly jeopardizes her livelihood because of her actions and speech. She has organized national conferences; she has done thousands of hours of sidewalk counseling; she has financially supported single mothers at a sacrificial level; she has rescued the corpses of aborted babies from dumpsters and kept them in her apartment or home until she could provide them with beautiful burials; she has been responsible for the closing of several abortion mills by revealing their illegal activities; she wrote Abandoned, one of the finest books about the prolife movement.
So clearly we cannot take her views lightly, not only because she has “paid her dues” but because her long term commitment to the unborn and sacrifices for them give her a special kind of knowledge. Thomas Aquinas argues that those who have a deep familiarity with a reality, can be said to have “connatural knowledge”, the kind of knowledge that someone who has worked with horses for years has of horses and those who have studied the qualities of wine, have of wine. Even if these people cannot fully explain their judgments, their judgments carry great weight. But, in fact, Prof Miller can fully explain her judgments in a voice and with a demeanor that powerfully convey her love for the unborn, their mothers and fathers.
Prof. Miller’s most basic argument is that it is necessary to enter abortion mills to attempt to rescue the lives of the babies whose mothers are about to abort them. Prof Miller insists that those babies deserve a chance to live. Sidewalk counseling is not effective in saving those lives – and, in fact, the mills the rescuers have chosen to enter are not apt for sidewalk counseling. In attempted rescues she and her fellow rescuers find they can have up to 15 minutes or so to talk to the women in a loving, gentle, and helpful fashion. Sometimes the women cannot be herded by staff into a protected space. The rescuers have seen women leave the abortion mill – one hopes, never to come back.
It strikes me that the most reasonable concern of the Sidewalk Advocacy Group is the possibility now or later, that such tactics jeopardize other more frequently successful rescues achieved by sidewalk counselors because they may result in buffer zones being imposed. Prof Miller states that such has not happened and that if and when it does it will be right to reconsider tactics. Why should we let the possibility of deterrence prevent us from saving lives?
As for the claim that the presence of the police is a serious negative, Miller postulates that whether then or later, it is not unlikely that some of the abortion-minded women and staff at abortion mills might come to realize what great sacrifices the rescuers are willing to make to save lives. How can people accept that pro-lifers really believe in the humanity and right to life of the unborn, unless we are willing to make tremendous sacrifices for them? Certainly, doing sidewalk counseling requires sacrifice, but it is in no way equivalent to doing time in jail.
There has always been a lot of disagreement in the prolife movement and that is to be expected. Should we show graphic pictures of aborted babies at rallies, during sidewalk counseling? Should we include mention of contraception in our literature, etc.? Should workers at pregnancy help centers mention God? Should we support compromise legislation? Concerning all these and other matters, people equally committed to stopping abortion have differing views. Yes, let us civilly share our views (as have both sides on this question) and respect the decisions of each other.
But let us not prevent such heroic people as Monica Migliorino Miller and those who do rescue work from doing what they think is most effective in saving lives of the unborn. Prof Miller’s home-made video with her low-key but passionate reasonability won the day, in my mind. I challenge you to watch Monica’s brief video defending rescues and ask yourself if there is any justice in trying to deter her from rescuing.

For a downloadable PDF version of the Janet E. Smith response click here .

Abby McIntyre Responds to
the SAFL anti-RRR video

Pro-lifers, expect that those among us will always be loving, supportive and kind. We expect them to see our efforts for a mutual cause and rejoice. This is not always the case. By nature of being human beings, we quibble on the appropriate method to fight abortion. Each member thinks, “I have the answer!” and we forget that we do not fight for our own sake, but for those who are exploited, killed, and voiceless. Division in the pro-life ranks is exactly what the other side wants—it may be even what the devil wants. A house divided will surely fall.


Sidewalk Advocates for Life recently released a video speaking out against a new initiative, the Red Rose Rescue. I am one of those Rescuers. I am acutely disappointed over the misrepresentation and the effort to malign what we are trying to convey. Our message is simple: we peacefully enter the abortion facility waiting room to offer love and support at the absolute last second before women make the irreversible choice to abort. We speak out in love for the unborn children who have been or are in danger of being aborted.

Abby under arrest Sept. 15, 2017

One of their claims is that those who participate in a Red Rose Rescue ignorantly enter abortion facilities only to be swiftly sent off to federal prison. While this may be an outcome, should we shy away from risk to save even one life from death and hundreds of lives from the pain of experiencing abortion? Furthermore, how do such consequences in any way affect the work of SAFL? I am not ill-informed on the possibilities for my actions. However, I ask, “how much is a life worth?” SAFL filmed half of their video inside a church; did they not notice the man hanging from a cross who endured a violent sacrifice so that each one of us might live? The essence of love is sacrifice. If we are not willing to sacrifice, we are not truly rooted in love.


In no way am I saying that every single person in the United States needs to be arrested by entering an abortion facility and refusing to leave. This would be imprudent, especially for those with families of their own for which to care. We need lawyers to support us, pregnancy help centers that can care for those who leave abortion facilities and a multitude of others in active support of the cause. But we must not shy away from risk.


I am part the millennial generation that is commonly chastised for ignorance, irrationality, and laziness. I wonder if these attributes stem not from our own natures, but from the fact that for 45 years we have been under attack. When our lawmakers and elders attempt to dictate whether our lives are worth a chance in the womb or not, there is difficulty in getting excited about rising to our fullest potentials. The idea of social justice presented to us is that we can only be free if we kill children. 60 million of my would-be friends and neighbors entered the world to be put into plastic “product of conception” bags. I am committed to ending that narrative, whatever it takes.


A Defense of the Pro-Life Rescue
A downloadable copy of this video transcript is available here .

See this very revealing video—a rare look at the difference between pro-lifers and those who support abortion:
Vitriol and Vulgarites: https://youtu.be/GVBLnclLh9s

In 2016 CPLS published this brand new pro-life educational tool—The 40 page booklet:
I was a Stranger

Over two years in the making—it features stunning abortion victim photos, each photo of a baby lost to abortion taken by your CPLS director is paired with insightful, moving and inspiring reflections—featuring Fr. Frank Pavone, David Daleiden, Joseph Scheidler, Jill Stanek, Abby Johnson and others!

We hope that this very unique literature will be used by sidewalk counselors, pregnancy help centers, given out to those who support abortion and will really make a contribution to ending the killing of the unborn!
You can order it here:
Or call: 1 800 437-5876
Read Dr. Miller's Review of Defenders of the Unborn-
The Pro-life Movement Before Roe v. Wade.
Click the picture.

Nationally known pro-life leader Jill Stanek featured the CPLS discussion on how to evaluate effective abortion victim photos (reprinted below) on her website blog--you may see it at:
http://www.jillstanek.com/2014/04/are-some-photos-of-abortion-victims-too-gory/  and feel free to join the discussion there.

It is important for the pro-life movement to begin to think about
the effective use of abortion victim photos. As someone who has spent countless hours photographing the victims of abortion, I offer this critique for your consideration.
Your feedback is welcome in the Com Box at the above link.


An Analysis of the Effective Use
of Abortion Victim Photos

by Monica Migliorino Miller

Nationally known, veteran pro-life leader Monica Migliorino Miller, director of Citizens for a Pro-Life Society urges the Pro-life Movement to reconsider and re-evaluate the necessary role that abortion victim photos (AVPs) play in bringing about an end to legalized abortion and establishing respect for human life.

Many of Miller’s ideas on this subject are available through her comprehensive article published September 2013 by New Oxford Review—available at http://www.newoxfordreview.org  for a mere $1.50 or by going to the homepage at: http://www.prolifesociety.org .

Miller is one of the few pro-lifers who has actually retrieved aborted babies from the trash and photographed their broken remains. See: http://imagesofabortion.com .

This blog highlights some of Miller’s important points with the goal of prompting discussion and new thinking on this important topic that continues to be hotly debated even within the ranks of the Pro-Life Movement.

  • “Graphic Images” or “Abortion Victim Photos”?
    No longer should pictures of aborted babies be referred to as “graphic images”. The movement should drop that term entirely. These images should be called “abortion victim photos” (AVPs for short) because that is what they are really all about and, moreover, not all photos of abortion victims, while disturbing, are necessarily graphic in nature. The term “abortion victim photos” is terminology that also advocates for the subject of the photos—as these are abortion victims—and not merely graphic images— words that give the instant impression that the subject matter is simply gruesome or repulsive which is not the point of the photos. Using the term AVPs aids the cause for the unborn, as the subjects of the photos are victims of injustice and the language we use should be aimed at helping others make that connection.
  • Life is Short – Use Better Abortion Photos
    While every photo of an abortion victim may be a true depiction of the abortion procedure and what happened to the unborn child, this does not mean that every photo is equal in terms of its effectiveness in raising awareness of the injustice of abortion. Pro-lifers need to begin to think more critically about the kinds of abortion victim photos they choose to display. Pro-lifers often tend to think that the bloodier photos are the more effective photos. This is not necessarily true.

    Whatever photos are selected, the subject of the photo, namely the abortion victim, should be easily recognized, the humanity of the unborn baby the central and immediate focus. Thus photos in which the blood and guts, visceral matter overwhelms, even submerges the abortion victim should be set aside in favor of photos in which the abused victim is easily recognized with whom the viewer can immediately identify—as opposed to emphasis on gruesome factors that are more likely to repel the viewer.

    We really want the viewer to see the abortion victim and not just a “graphic image” of an abortion. It should be realized that all that blood featured in some abortion victim photos is not the blood of the baby—it is the blood of the mother that attends the abortion procedure. Even for this reason the visceral material in the photo should be secondary to the actual abortion victim.

The 3 photos below are examples of AVPs in which the subject of the photo is overwhelmed by, immersed in blood matter and uterine tissue.


While photos 4, 5, 6 and 7 below are graphic, the aborted baby is clearly the focus of the image. Blood and other matter are secondary to the subject.

  • Not All Abortion Victim Photos are Graphic Images
    This is a distinction that is not in any way sufficiently appreciated especially by those in the Pro-Life Movement who oppose the use of AVPs— and who certainly reject their public display. We need to begin to appreciate that AVPs represent a spectrum from very graphic to much less graphic images. Given that such a distinction exists, those who oppose their use have very little foundation upon which to do so. Some images certainly and rightly demonstrate the violence of abortion in all its graphic horror—the shattered remnants of bodies torn apart. Other images however, while still obviously depicting abortion victims, are truly less graphic in nature. Thus perhaps we can begin to move these arguments along that
         1) AVPs, whether graphic or less so, are necessary to the success of the pro-life cause and
         2) Choosing less graphic images is an option and
         3) The use of AVPs is central to the pro-life cause and thus those who use AVPs
             are not the  fringe element of the Movement but mainstream pro-lifers.

    The photos below, while disturbing, are not overtly graphic—indeed some may not be graphic at all.
  • Responses to the Most Common Objections
  1. Children will see the AVPs The crisis of legalized abortion that has claimed the lives of 56 million innocent human beings requires that the truth be publicly exposed. The magnitude of the injustice overrides the possibility that children will see the pictures. It simply makes no sense to forego the public exposure of a national slaughter that has sent tens of millions of children to their deaths for the sake of sparing children who might see the photos and be affected by them. There is absolutely no proof that children who see such images suffer any lasting negative effects.
  2. Women who have had abortions will be disturbed by the AVPs The primary victims of abortion are the millions of unborn children who perish under the law in a violent death, in a nation that at least tolerates, and at worst advocates, such killing. Again the enormity of the injustice requires that the public be awakened to the slaughter. Furthermore there simply is no one-size-fits-all response of post-abortive women to such images. In addition we should consider how AVPs actually prevent women from getting abortions in the first place thus sparing them a life of grief and regret.
  3. Women who have had abortions will be disturbed by the AVPs The primary victims of abortion are the millions of unborn children who perish under the law in a violent death, in a nation that at least tolerates, and at worst advocates, such killing. Again the enormity of the injustice requires that the public be awakened to the slaughter. Furthermore there simply is no one-size-fits-all response of post-abortive women to such images. In addition we should consider how AVPs actually prevent women from getting abortions in the first place thus sparing them a life of grief and regret.


The use of graphic images of abortion victims in pro-life work has in more recent decades become a point of conflict and debate within the pro-life movement itself, especially the public display of such images. Monica Migliorino Miller’s recently published article is an unprecedented comprehensive examination of this issue. Published in the September 2013 New Oxford Review

The article it is now available on the NOR website for a limited time at: http://www.newoxfordreview.org/article.jsp?did=0913-miller
THE ARTICLE IS POSTED ON THIS SITE AT: http://www.prolifesociety.com/pages/ArticlesAndPublications/norGraphicImages.pdf

The author has herself retrieved hundreds of aborted babies from trash containers and spent hundreds of hours photographing the bodies. Miller argues strongly that photos of abortion victims play a vital role in the efforts of the right-to-life movement to establish respect for the lives of the unborn and abolish the injustice of abortion. Among other areas of discussion Miller provides a history of the use of these images in the pro-life movement. However, she urges that the time has come for the movement to evaluate which photos of abortion victims are most effective. This means pro-lifers should be more critical and sophisticated in the selection of photos displayed in public, in literature and educational materials. She states: “Not all abortion victim photos are equal” and goes on to explain that it is a mistake that the “gorier and bloodier the image, the more effective it will be in depicting the injustice of abortion.”

Miller agrees that abortion victim photos will innately contain graphic elements, but argues that such aspects of the photos must be secondary to the subject of the abortion victims presented in the photos. To the viewer of a “graphic image” the abortion victim must be immediately recognizably human. Miller explains:

“Blood and extraneous uterine matter should not overwhelm the aborted baby in the photo. Indeed even a kind of mathematical ratio can be used to evaluate the usefulness of a graphic image. If the blood and gore is more than or even equal to the actual baby—such a photo should be set aside in favor of an image in which the actual human victim is primary. It is not only or primarily the violence of abortion that pro-lifers should display to the world, but the actual hidden and silent human victim of abortion will be the focus of the more effective images.” Miller continues:

“The viewer of the image of an aborted baby should be able to identify with the victim — not simply be shocked or repulsed by the blood-drenched image. The photo should provoke pathos, pity, sorrow, and a response to the injustice done to the baby, whose humanity is obvious in the midst of the tragedy and violence. To the majority of viewers whom pro-lifers are trying to reach, that first glance is the most important — indeed, it might not just be the first glance but the only glance — and thus its impact in drawing the viewer into the humanity of the victim cannot be squandered.”

Miller also urges that the pro-life movement drop the term “graphic images” when referring to photos of aborted babies. Many abortion photos—even effective ones are indeed extremely “graphic images”—but the term itself does not capture or encompass the essence of this type of photography. She states: “The movement needs to stop using that term. Instead we should refer to these pictures as “abortion victim photos” or “abortion victim photography.”

Distinctions exist between a graphic image that instantly repulses the viewer, an image with an appropriate proportion of extraneous graphic elements, and photos of abortion victims that certainly are disturbing, but in which the blood and gore is nearly absent. Miller’s article calls for a deeper appreciation for these distinctions and states: “Those who oppose the use of ‘graphic images’ need not necessarily oppose photos of abortion victims per se. Whatever side one may take in the debate, given that a difference exists between an excessively graphic image and an image of an abortion victim — between a repulsive image and a disturbing image— pro-lifers who object to the use of all abortion-victim photography should reexamine and move beyond that objection.”

Miller states: “There are many great pro-lifers who are dedicated to the display of abortion victim photos. What they do is essential to the movement. Their work should be supported and encouraged. I simply want to urge those of us on the front lines to look at abortion victim photos in a new way—to not be threatened or afraid to re-evaluate what we are doing and urge the selection of photos in which the tragic victim of abortion ‘however graphic’ is primary and obvious.”

The New Oxford Review Article covers the following topics:
  1. History of the use of these images in the pro-life movement
  2. Summary of the recent debate
  3. Responses to the objections as to their use
  4. Why we need to stop using the term “graphic images” and instead use the term “abortion victim photos”
  5. Why not all abortion images are equal in their effectiveness and how to judge a bad photo versus a good one
  6. The ethics of abortion victim photography
  7. When and where to use the photos


This 10 minute video shows close-up just some of the aborted babies who were buried in 1988—taken from the trash as they were left out on a loading dock at the Vital Med pathology lab in Northbrook, IL. Citizens for a Pro-life Society and the Pro-Life Action League retrieved over 5000 bodies from the Vital Med trash and provided these victims with humane burials. The babies in the video were buried by CPLS with 1200 others at Holy Cross Cemetery, Milwaukee, WI, Sept.10, 1988 ALL OF THIS IS CHRONICLED IN ABANDONED— THE UNTOLD STORY OF THE ABORTION WARS-- SEE LINK TO BOOK IN SIDE BAR


New -- Great Review of Abandoned

Monica Migliorino Miller’s Abandoned: The Untold Story of the Abortion Wars resists singular classification: It is equal parts memoir, documentary, and a history of her pro-life work. Her exposé hails from the front lines of the war on babies; it is packed with heart-wrenching drama that follows pro-life battles on the ground and in the courtroom. Miller is founder of Citizens for a Pro-Life Society and is associate professor of religious studies at Madonna University in Michigan. She is also one of a small group of intrepid souls who dumpster-dived to recover the destroyed bodies of abandoned, aborted babies, and arranged burials and funeral Masses for thousands of them.

Read More


A new book by Monica Miller, Ph.D
tells the story of a life fighting abortion

Reviewed by Mark Sullivan (Catholic World Report: December 4, 2012)

“The time may come when we date the beginning of the collapse of the Soviet system from the appearance of Gulag,”wrote a German reviewer of Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn’s masterpiece, The Gulag Archipelago, 1918-1956: An Experiment in Literary Investigation. It may sound crazy, but the time may also come when we date the end of legalized abortion in the United States from the publication of Abandoned: The Untold Story of the Abortion Wars by Monica Migliorino Miller (Saint Benedict Press, 2012).

I recently began reading the abridged version of Gulag, and I was stuck by Solzhenitsyn’s descriptions of the injustice and the powerlessness of the people in communist Russia — in particular, by how fittingly his descriptions of the power structures of the Soviet system could be applied to the institutions that promote and protect legalized abortion in this country. I thought it would make an interesting story, so I requested a review copy of Abandoned. I thought it would make a good point of departure to talk about Solzhenitsyn.

Read More.....

Help us continue our
life-saving work.
Support Our Work Through Real Estate for Life

Catholic Speakers Bureau, CMG Booking.
The Best Secular News Coverage of Any Pro-Life Related Event And it is Coverage of the Burial of Aborted Babies!
Video Links Below
Requiem for
the Disappeared
New York Times Videos
the Owosso Incident
Woman's Choice
Clinic Investigation
Bishop Boyea Buries
Womans Choice Babies
CPLS Pickets Obama
at U of MI
Nun Arrested
at Notre Dame
Children Protest
Planned Parenthood

© 2018